The aftermath of the Council of Chalcedin 451 AD The, frist Great Schism and Political Impact

The Great Schism and Political Impact

• The Council of Chalcedon resulted in a deep and enduring schism within Christianity, separating the churches that accepted its decrees (Byzantine/Eastern Orthodox and Western/Roman Catholic) from those that rejected them, including the Coptic Church and other Oriental Orthodox traditions.
• The Coptic Church firmly rejected the Chalcedonian formula of two natures (dyophysitism), viewing it as risking a division in Christ's person, and instead upheld miaphysitism—the doctrine of one united incarnate nature of the Word of God.
• Miaphysitism, rooted in the teachings of St Cyril of Alexandria, affirms the full divinity and full humanity of Christ, united in one nature without confusion, separation, division, or alteration, preserving the unity of His person.
• This theological divergence created intense internal religious conflict and political instability within the Byzantine Empire, as Egypt—a vital province—resisted imperial religious policy.
• The religious division significantly weakened imperial cohesion and military readiness, contributing to the empire's vulnerability during the Arab conquests of Egypt in the 7th century.

The Exile of Pope Dioscorus

• Pope Dioscorus I of Alexandria, a leading defender of miaphysite theology, had previously presided over the Second Council of Ephesus in 449 AD, which upheld St Cyril's formula but was later condemned by Chalcedonians as the "Robber Council".
• At Chalcedon, Dioscorus was accused of misconduct, deposed from his patriarchal seat, and exiled by imperial decree to Gangra in Paphlagonia, where he died in 454 AD.
• Among the Egyptian faithful, Dioscorus was revered not as a heretic but as a courageous confessor of the orthodox faith and a powerful symbol of resistance against imposed Byzantine theology.

Appointment of Proterius

• In the wake of Dioscorus's deposition, the Byzantine Emperor appointed Proterius, a Chalcedonian priest, as the new Patriarch of Alexandria, disregarding the preferences of the local Egyptian clergy and populace.
• This imposition, backed by military force, provoked widespread outrage and led to violent unrest in Alexandria, with severe clashes erupting between Egyptian Christians and Byzantine troops.
• The tensions culminated in 457 AD when Proterius was murdered by an angry mob during Holy Week, dramatically illustrating the overwhelming rejection of Chalcedonian authority by the majority of Egyptians.

Dual Patriarchates in Egypt

• Following 451 AD, Egypt witnessed the establishment of two parallel and rival patriarchal lines in Alexandria, reflecting the deep ecclesiastical divide.
• The Melkite ("royal" or imperial) Patriarchate supported the Council of Chalcedon, aligned closely with Byzantine emperors, used Greek in liturgy, and primarily served the Greek-speaking elite and imperial interests.
• The Coptic Patriarchate rejected Chalcedon, adhered steadfastly to miaphysite theology, maintained native Egyptian leadership, and enjoyed the loyal support of the vast majority of the local population.
• This dual structure turned Alexandria into a city with competing church hierarchies, each claiming legitimacy and controlling separate networks of churches and clergy.

Persecution of the Copts

• The Coptic refusal to accept Chalcedon's decrees triggered brutal persecution orchestrated by Byzantine authorities, including the confiscation of churches, mass arrests of bishops and priests, widespread exiles, and executions of resistant believers.
• In 452 AD, Emperor Marcian issued harsh decrees isolating and punishing clergy who refused to subscribe to Chalcedon, marking the beginning of systematic repression.
• Copts regarded this era as a direct continuation of earlier Roman persecutions, often describing it as a "new age of martyrdom" inflicted tragically by fellow Christians rather than pagans.

Public Loyalty to Pope Dioscorus

• Despite his exile and deposition, the Egyptian Christian population continued to venerate Pope Dioscorus as their true spiritual leader and the legitimate defender of the apostolic faith handed down from St Mark.
• This enduring loyalty sustained organised resistance, enabling the secret election and underground operation of Miaphysite successors, such as Timothy II Aelurus, who evaded capture while shepherding the faithful.

Rejection of the State Patriarch

• The Egyptian people categorically rejected Proterius and subsequent state-appointed Melkite patriarchs, viewing them as foreign intruders, illegitimate figures, and mere instruments of Byzantine imperial control.
• This widespread rejection reinforced the Coptic Church's drive toward ecclesiastical independence, bolstered a growing sense of Egyptian national identity, and intensified resistance to cultural and linguistic Hellenisation imposed from Constantinople.

Doctrinal Labels and Clarifications

• Post-Chalcedon labelling branded the Coptic and allied churches as "Monophysite" (implying belief in only one nature absorbing the other), while Chalcedonian churches were termed "Diophysite".
• The "Monophysite" label was historically inaccurate and polemical, as the Coptic Church explicitly rejected the extreme monophysitism of Eutyches and adhered to St Cyril's balanced miaphysite formula.
• Contemporary theological scholarship and ecumenical dialogues, especially from the late 20th century onwards, have recognised that much of the ancient dispute stemmed from semantic and terminological misunderstandings rather than substantive heresy, leading to affirmations of a fundamentally shared Christological faith.

Renewed Age of Martyrdom

• Emperor Marcian's enforcement measures escalated persecution, affecting clergy and laity alike, with thousands imprisoned, tortured, or executed for their fidelity to miaphysite belief.
• The Coptic tradition remembers this period somberly as "Chalcedon, the Ominous", highlighting the painful irony of suffering inflicted by fellow Christians in positions of imperial power.

Specific Martyrs

• Numerous high-ranking figures and ordinary believers became martyrs, including St Macarius, Bishop of Edko, who was killed for his outspoken refusal to accept Chalcedon's decrees.
• Many monks, priests, and bishops were exiled to desolate regions or perished in prisons; their lives and sacrifices are commemorated in the Coptic Synaxarium and preserved through rich monastic hagiographical traditions.

The Henoticon Attempt (482 AD)

• In 482 AD, Emperor Zeno promulgated the Henoticon (Act of Union), a compromise document designed to reconcile Chalcedonians and miaphysites by avoiding direct reference to Chalcedon's controversial formulas.
• While some Miaphysite leaders, including Pope Peter Mongus, initially accepted it, the Henoticon ultimately failed to achieve lasting unity, being rejected by strict Miaphysites and by Rome, resulting in the Acacian Schism that lasted until 519 AD.

Persistent Theological Identity

• Throughout the turmoil, the Coptic Church steadfastly maintained its commitment to St Cyril's miaphysite formula, preserving it through sacred liturgy, extensive monastic writings, and the enduring influence of the Catechetical School of Alexandria.
• The Bohairic dialect of the Coptic language remained central to worship, ensuring theological continuity even amid isolation from the broader imperial church.

Cultural and National Growth

• Paradoxically, Byzantine persecution fostered greater internal unity and spurred remarkable cultural flourishing, evident in distinctive Coptic art, hymnody, iconography, and literary production.
• Monasteries emerged as vital spiritual fortresses, cultural repositories, and centres of quiet resistance, helping to forge a uniquely Egyptian Christian identity separate from Byzantine Greek influences.

Continued Byzantine Persecutions (5th–7th Centuries)

• Imperial efforts to enforce Chalcedon persisted under emperors such as Justin I and Justinian I, who repeatedly exiled Coptic patriarchs and installed Melkite replacements.
• Monasticism flourished as a refuge for the persecuted, with influential leaders like St Shenoute the Archimandrite rallying spiritual and communal resistance.
• A brief respite came during the Persian Sassanid occupation of Egypt (619–629 AD), but Byzantine reconquest restored persecution until the Arab Muslim conquest in 639–642 AD finally ended Chalcedonian imperial dominance.

All references are in the file attached.in arabic.